SPONSORED BY DUALENTRY
5 signs you’ve outgrown your ERP that most finance teams miss
Most ERP switches start for weak reasons: a slick demo, a peer company that just moved, a team that dislikes the screens.
The real signs are quieter. They show up in the close calendar, the reconciliations and the people you can’t let go on vacation.
Here are 5 I check in my first week with a finance team, with the test for each.
1. The close gets longer while volume stays flat
The average close is 6.2 business days. Plot your last 6 months. If close days climb and transactions don’t, the system is the drag.
2. Three people give you three revenue numbers
73% of finance and IT leaders say they lack a single source of truth. Ask three people for last month’s revenue and compare the answers.
3. Billing never ties to the GL without a person
Cross-system reconciliation is the #1 task finance teams want gone. Check how long the tie-out takes each month, and who owns it.
4. You pay for tools that only exist to patch the ERP
List every one and add up the annual bill. That number belongs in your switch decision.
5. One person out, and the close stalls
68% say the close bottlenecks when key people are out. Name the people your close can’t run without. More than one is a risk.
Want all 20?
I built the full checklist with DualEntry. It covers 20 signs across close, revenue, entities, integrations, audit and people, each with its test and source, on one page.
DualEntry is an AI-native ERP for mid-market and growth-stage companies. On Thursday at FATE in New York, co-founder Santiago Nestares told me most of their customers migrate in under 24 hours. If three or more of these signs sound familiar, it’s worth a look.
P.S. This feature is a paid partnership with DualEntry.
WELCOME TO ISSUE NO #107
Consulting | Shop | Website | Newsletter | Speaking
📆 Today’s Rundown
Hey {{first_name}} 👋, I hope you’re having a great week! In the last issue, we discussed about How to Evaluate a Fractional CFO Agency, and now we are moving with the second topic from Fractional CFO series.
Let’s talk about ⬇️
How much fractional CFO do you actually need?
Most fractional CFO quotes start with a number. $6K. $12K. $18K.
Almost none start with a list.
That’s backwards. The retainer should come last. First you write down the decisions you need to make this quarter, then you estimate the hours each one takes. The price follows from that.
Last week was about telling two $8K proposals apart. This week covers how much to buy, and when renting a CFO stops making sense.
how most cfo retainers get priced
TL;DR
The job is the decision
Size it in hours
What each stage usually pays
📋 FOUND IN A BOARD DECK
Score the work they show you
When to stop renting
Five questions for the first call
Two mistakes I skipped last week
The job is the decision
A fractional CFO is a job description. It doesn’t guarantee better decisions.
At $5-50M ARR, the decisions usually look like this:
Runway under three growth scenarios
Margin impact of a pricing change
Payback on the next five hires
What the board should decide, and what it only needs to hear about
If a candidate can’t explain how they’d model those in the first conversation, you’re talking to a reporting vendor.
Size it in hours
Four steps.
1. List this quarter’s decisions. The real ones, the calls you’d make differently with better numbers.
2. Put hours against each one. Rough benchmarks:
Work | Hours |
|---|---|
One board deck cycle, with commentary | 15-25 |
Full runway model rebuild | 20-40 |
Monthly close support | 10-20 a month |
3. Add 30-50% if you’re fundraising. Data room requests, investor model questions, and scenario reruns all land in the same weeks.
4. Match the hours to a rate band. Let the scope pick the package. Avoid working the other way around.
Here’s a quick example, using the low end of each range.
One board cycle (15) plus a runway rebuild (20) plus three months of close support (30) comes to 65 hours a quarter. That’s about 22 hours a month.
Now add a raise. 65 hours plus 30-50% is roughly 85-98 hours a quarter, or 28-33 hours a month.
Same company, same team. The fundraise quarter pushes you up a band.
the fundraise quarter. same team, 30-50% more hours.
What each stage usually pays
Stage | Hours a month | Monthly retainer | Typical scope |
|---|---|---|---|
Pre-seed to $1M ARR | 5-10 | $1,500-$2,000 | Cap table setup, basic model review, light advisory |
$1M-$3M ARR | 10-15 | $2,500-$8,000 | Board pack, monthly cadence, cohort-level metrics |
$3M-$10M ARR | 15-25 | $6,000-$12,000 | Investor-grade model, fundraising readiness, department planning |
$10M-$20M ARR | 20-35 | $10,000-$18,000 | Weekly ops cadence, board deck ownership, unit economics governance |
$20M+ ARR | 30-50 | $15,000-$25,000 | Full-scope strategic finance, capital structure, sourcing the finance hire |
The example company above sits at 22 hours in a normal quarter. That’s the $3M-$10M band. In a raise quarter it runs 28-33 hours, which is the $10M-$20M band’s workload.
If a proposal’s hours and price don’t line up with the decisions on your list, ask why.
measure the foot before you buy the shoe
Meet Seller Agent. It knows your deals
Your AI knows a lot. But does it know your deals?
Meet Seller Agent. It follows your calls, emails, and buyer activity when you're not in the room, then proposes updates to your plan, next steps, owners, and deadlines. You approve.
Always on, in every deal.
📋 FOUND IN A BOARD DECK
One thing that shouldn’t have made it into the room.
The slide: “Cash and runway.” Big number in the middle: 22 months.
What wasn’t there: the cash model’s number. That one said 17 months, because it included the Q2 hiring plan the board had approved one meeting earlier.
Two files, two answers, and nobody owned the gap.
The fix: one source of truth for cash, runway, and the board model. The deck pulls from the model, the model carries the approved hiring plan, and a named person signs off on both before the meeting.

board deck: 22 months. cash model: 17.
Score the work they show you
Last week’s scorecard was about the call. This one scores the work product. Give each candidate 1-5 on five criteria and add up the total.
Criterion | Ask them | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
SaaS-specific modeling | Walk me through how you model deferred revenue and NRR | Generic answers that blur bookings and recognized revenue |
Assumptions transparency | Show me every input and who owns it | Locked cells, no assumption log, “trust the output” |
Board-deck philosophy | Show me a sample deck and what it recommended | Charts with no recommendation or trade-off |
Cadence discipline | What’s the monthly rhythm, and what happens when a number is late? | A vague or ad hoc schedule |
CAC/LTV treatment | One number or a cohort range? | A single blended LTV:CAC presented as fact |
That last row matters more than it looks. A blended number hides cohort variance. The board ends up debating whether the number is right, and nobody gets to what to do about it.
Run the same scorecard on internal options too: a full-time CFO, a Head of Finance, a controller, or an FP&A analyst.
When to stop renting
A fully loaded full-time CFO at a $5-15M ARR company runs about $500K-$800K a year.
A fractional engagement with the same strategic scope runs about $87K-$167K. Even the top of that range is about a third of the bottom of the full-time range.
So when does the full-time hire make sense? Here’s what operators and investors have said publicly.
Jason Lemkin (SaaStr): “At $20m in ARR, it’s not too early for a CFO or more practically at least a real VP of Finance.” At $2M ARR, he says a real controller or seasoned finance person, even part-time, will often pay for itself.
Lemkin again, in an editor’s note on an OnlyCFO piece: plenty of companies hire a “CFO” somewhere around $10-30M ARR when what they actually need is a VP or SVP of Finance.
Christoph Janz (Point Nine): “When we’re at $5–10M in ARR or so, a great CFO might almost pay for him/herself.” He also wrote that a seasoned part-time CFO at a few million in ARR can push the full-time hire out to around $10M ARR.
Put it together and the pattern is pretty clear. Below roughly $20M ARR, most companies don’t have a title problem. They have fragmented data, assumptions nobody owns, and no repeatable cadence. A full-time hire doesn’t fix any of those by default.
a $600k cfo at a $6m arr company
Five questions for the first call
Thirty minutes. Five questions.
Walk me through your last board deck for a company at our stage. What did it recommend, and what happened?
Show me a live model, not a template. Where are the assumptions, and who owns each one?
How do you handle CAC and LTV when cohorts behave differently?
What’s your monthly cadence, and what’s the escalation path when a number is late or wrong?
If our runway forecast and our board deck disagreed, whose job is it to reconcile them, and how fast?
Most candidates stumble on number five. A strong answer describes one source of truth for cash, runway, and the board model. See the board deck segment above for what happens without it.

“whose job is it to reconcile them?”
Two mistakes I skipped last week
Treating a bookkeeping provider as CFO-equivalent. Clean books are the foundation. They don’t add up to a financial story an investor will fund. Budget for recordkeeping and for strategic judgment as two separate lines.
Skipping the reference check on the model. Everyone checks references on the relationship. Few check the work. Ask a reference client to screen-share a real model they use today. Look at whether the assumptions are current, dated, and owned by someone.

the reference check nobody asks for
The Bottom Line
A fractional CFO is priced by hours, but you’re really buying decisions. So start with the decisions.
Three things to carry out of this.
Write the list first. Put hours against each decision, add 30-50% in a raise quarter, then look at the rate band.
Score the work product. Ask for the model, the assumption log, and the deck that made a recommendation.
Don’t hire full-time on a title. Below roughly $20M ARR, the gap is usually decision cadence and assumption ownership. A rented CFO who owns both will get you further.
Reply “HOURS” and I’ll send the CFO hours sizing sheet. List your decisions, it adds up the hours, applies the fundraise uplift, and shows which stage band and retainer range you land in.
If a proposal ever quotes you a price before asking a single question, you have my permission to quote this issue back.
Earn free gifts 🎁
{{first_name}} You can get free stuff for referring friends & family to my newsletter 👇
50 referrals - Cash Flow Models Bundle 💰
10 referrals - SaaS Financial Model 📊
{{rp_personalized_text}}
Copy & Paste this link: {{rp_refer_url}}
Alex Stojanovic
Chief Finance Ninja | Fiscallion
Fractional CFO & FP&A Agency
P.S. Whenever you’re ready, here’s how I can help:
Free Consultation: Book your strategy call.
Keynote Speaking: Schedule me for your event.
Sponsor my Newsletter: Reach 5,000+ subscribers.





